Locke, Toleration and the Rationality of Persecution
Files
Description
This is a paper about John Locke's argument for toleration, or, more accurately, it is a paper about the main line of argument which appears in Locke's work A Letter on Toleration. It is not intended – as so many papers on Locke's political philosophy are these days—as a historical analysis of his position. I am not going to say very much at all about the development (in some ways the quite remarkable development) of Locke's views on the subject, or about the contemporary debate on religious toleration in which Locke, first as an academic then as a political agitator, was involved, or about the historical circumstances of the Letter's composition. No doubt these are worthy subjects for a paper, but not, I think, for a volume devoted to toleration as an issue in modern political philosophy. Rather, I want to consider the Lockian case as a political argument—that is as a practical intellectual resource that can be abstracted from the antiquity of its context and deployed in the modern debate about liberal theories of justice and political morality. To put it bluntly, I want to consider whether Locke's case is worth anything as an argument which might dissuade someone here and now from actions of intolerance and persecution. There is a further somewhat more abstract reason for examining the Lockian argument. In its content and structure the Lockian case is quite different from the more familiar and more commonly cited arguments of John Stuart Mill. Even if, as I shall claim, it turns out to be an inadequate and unconvincing argument, one that in the last resort radically underestimates the complexity of the problem it addresses, still its distinctive structure and content tell us a lot about the possibilities and limits of liberal argumentation in this area. Those insights and the contrast with the more familiar arguments of Mill may well contribute considerably to our understanding of modern liberal theories of toleration and the 'neutral' state.
Source Publication
Justifying Toleration: Conceptual and Historical Perspectives
Source Editors/Authors
Susan Mendus
Publication Date
1988
Recommended Citation
Waldron, Jeremy, "Locke, Toleration and the Rationality of Persecution" (1988). Faculty Chapters. 1655.
https://gretchen.law.nyu.edu/fac-chapt/1655
