Document Type

Article

Publication Title

American University Law Review Forum

Abstract

In The Rise of the ‘Immigrant-as-injury’ Theory of State Standing, Professor Jennifer Lee Koh identifies and critiques an emerging theory of state standing that treats the existence of immigrants as an injury to the state for purposes of challenging federal immigration policies. Koh persuasively critiques the immigrant-as-injury theory on anti-subordination, federalism, and democratic accountability grounds. As she explains, the theory relies on flawed narratives about immigrants’ undesirability and. state powerlessness over immigration policy to enable states to pursue politicized goals. This Response builds on Koh’s critique to cast the immigrant-as-injury theory as a form of “backdoor discrimination” against immigrants in violation of Equal Protection principles. The Response argues that acceptance of the immigrant-as-injury theory permits an end-run around Equal Protection itself.

First Page

147

Volume

72

Publication Date

2023

Download

Share

COinS